Blog Search

Friday, 13 January 2017

Not your normal day on the road!

The general perception of government departments (sometimes with justification! ) is of inflexible and slow to act bureaucracies, which are totally out of touch with the general public.  Well, I've just had that notion stood totally on its head, at least in the instance I'm about to describe.

I guess that motorcyclists worldwide have a much higher accident rate per capita than cars, trucks etc and the cost of medical care from trauma is pretty high.  I'm sure that a lot of public servants would like to see us gone from the roads.  Accepting personal responsibility for our riding standards and raising skills is one clear path to reducing the risk of serious harm but leaving that aside for now, it is fantastic to find a government department who are working in a positive manner to improve the lot of riders - who'd have thought it???

 The Coromandel Peninsula which I live on has a low static population, it's pretty remote and has challenging, twisty roads that run by the sea and over the Coromandel mountain range.  In other words, it's a bikers paradise and the so-called Coromandel Loop has an international reputation. Because it attracts lots of bikers, a percentage of them have a distinct lack of skill and very quickly run out of talent on this unforgiving road.  Consequently, it has a high accident rate.

Enter the NZ Transport Agency (NZTA).  Its broad purpose is to deliver transport solutions within NZ on behalf of the government - a pretty wide mandate. Rather than introduce punitive measures against motorcyclists, they looked at initiatives which would positively benefit the 2-wheeled community in conjunction with some other specialist government agencies.  Over the last couple of years, they chose the southern part of the Loop to implement a range of measures which would be of  particular benefit to bikers.

Some of these measures included:
Sealing property entrances to stop gravel ingress onto the road
Better design of roadside storm drains
Improved safety barriers for motorcycles
Better signage and reflective chevrons for bends etc (advisory speeds are marked on signage in NZ)
Modification of roadside cliffs, banks and foliage for better sightlines
Improved road surface and clean-up after repairs
More roadside emergency helicopter landing pads in remote areas. "The medical Golden Hour"
Perceptual countermeasures (Different road markings and other visible cues on deceptive corners, designed to reduce the rider’s speed, improve their lane position and give greater separation from traffic travelling in the opposite direction.)

The graphic below is part of an explanatory pamphlet showing the Southern Loop.  The letter P shows where perceptual countermeasures have been employed and H is where helicopter pads have been installed.  The other initiatives have been implemented as appropriate throughout the Loop.  The full pamphlet can be accessed by clicking here HERE :

Southern Coromandel Loop initiatives

The million dollar question is have they worked?  From personal experience, the maintenance-oriented improvements and signage certainly have.  It's too early for any statistically valid data from the perceptual countermeasures but it's certainly prompted some discussions among riders on bike forums.  Overseas research (check the internet) suggests that it's particularly useful for riders (and drivers) with less experience of riding in those conditions. Riders with higher levels of training tend to use a range of other cues to enhance their situational awareness.

Just before Christmas, I was invited to a preliminary meeting with NZTA and associated agencies to discuss extending the initiatives to the northern section of the Loop.  The invitation was extended because of both my IAM training and being a local from Coromandel Town. Several other riders from the wider region were invited for their input too.  The first thing which struck us was that the various agency representatives were very professional and it was clear that our input was valued.  A number of the agency reps are also keen riders which was an excellent sign!

Last week, I received an invitation to accompany the various agency reps to drive round the northern part of the Loop.  This is it:

Northern Coromandel Loop

Met them at Kopu at the southern end of the Loop for a clockwise inspection of the route.  They had detailed motorcycle accident statistics over a number of years marked on the maps, together with the severity and details of the accident.  Each location was investigated for sightlines, road conditions and many other variables.  In addition, certain spots were investigated to see if perceptual countermeasures would be of potential value.  Possible locations for rescue helicopter landing pads were also identified.  My role as a regular rider on the Coromandel Loop was to give feedback on road conditions, sightlines, tar bleed and so on which constitute a potential hazard to riders.  One example is a particular tight bend with a cliff on one side and the sea on the other.  The base of the cliff is within half a metre of the road and particularly after wind or rain, pea gravel comes off the cliff and settles in the nearside lane.  Limited forward view makes it an even bigger potential hazard.  All dutifully recorded by NZTA for appropriate remedial action!

Blind downhill  25 km/hr left-hander with a sheer drop on one side - the site of a serious accident

The Coromandel-Whangapoua Hill 5 minutes from home - biker heaven! 

Potentially risky overtake with limited forward view


In the photo above, the SUV driver has relied on the logging truck driver signalling that an overtake was ok because of his view from a higher vantage point.  The SUV driver would not have been able to have a clear view from the lower vantage point because of the small trees to the left of the photo. In some locations, clearing some of the vegetation to improve sightlines is carried out to mitigate risk.

In the photo immediately below, this is the approximate view the SUV driver would have had as he crossed back onto his side of the road.  Any approaching vehicle would be masked by the vegetation and during the overtaking manoeuvre, there would have been even less visibility.  Buggered if I would have put my safety (and that of my family) in the hands of the logging truck driver in this particular set of circumstances even if he was trying to do the right thing - would you?

View of oncoming traffic obscured by vegetation

Unforgiving corner with steep drop.  Our house is on the hill in the background!

The last 30 km of the northern part of the Loop is across a stretch of road shared with the southern part where remedial work has already been implemented and we stopped to look at a few spots.  The two photos below show just one example of perceptual countermeasures on one corner.

Downhill traffic is in the lane on the right of the photo

The broad intent is catch the rider's attention and to slightly channel them away from traffic heading in the opposite direction.  Also note that the plastic vertical edge marker posts are closely spaced as a guide to corner severity, particularly as they are reflective at night.

View in the opposite direction

I've deliberately avoided going into technical details on this post but wanted to give NZTA and their associated agencies accolades for being so proactive on behalf of motorcyclists in this instance. Pragmatic people, good listeners, easy to talk to and consummately professional.   As I've been typing this, an email from NZTA has arrived with all the action items for checking - how good is that??  Really impressed and pleased to have contributed in some small way.

Before finishing, it's worth mentioning that one of the other government agencies represented on this project, the Accident Compensation Corporation (ACC); has contracted qualified providers to run heavily subsidised one day refresher courses for motorcyclists under the Ride Forever banner.  There are 3 levels designed to cater for different levels of experience plus a specialist course for urban scooters.  More info HERE .  The most expensive course is $50 for a whole day so no-one can claim that the cost is prohibitive!  Plaudits are due for the holistic approach to improving motorcycle safety as opposed to trying to legislate us off the road!  These initiatives aren't the complete answer to improving motorcycle safety but it's a great step in the right direction.  Taking personal responsibility for one's own riding standards is still the big ticket item!


19 comments:

  1. What great proactivity! I was just watching Grand Designs NZ last night on the idiot box and the featured house was an "earthship" (google it) being built on the Coromandle. I was impressed with the can-do attitude of not only the builders but the fact that the Coromandle Mayor showed up to have a look and commend the builders shows an impressive level of connectivity between ordinary residents and the Guvment. We could only dream of such collaboration here the prison island. Good to see that they soliciting expert advice too. ;)
    P.S. You live in one very special place Geoff! Lucky bugger!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi Dave and thanks! It's easy to grizzle about public servants but this is one example of great collaboration and I'm sure that there are lots more. I'm sure that having bikers among NZTA ranks is a real benefit too. The current President of IAM NZ is a senior public servant too. Must infiltrate more bikers :-).

    Coromandel is indeed a nice place, probably helped by it being a fair distance from major centres - a blessing and a curse! Excellent mountain bike tracks if you ever fancy trying one on a layover. Warm bed and cold beer :-)

    ReplyDelete
  3. Good stuff Geoff, always cool to hear officialdom has a down to earth human touch! My take on the southern loop is that the improvements are practical for most riders, with only those lacking in basic skills now struggling. Oh, and maybe that small portion of riders who just go too fast for the conditions...

    The truck being overtaken by the car highlights a common problem of NZ's narrow and winding roads, not always enough places for truckers to ease over and allow following traffic to sneak past safely.

    Now looking forward to hearing of, then seeing improvements made to the northern loop!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Rob. Yeah, all I wanted to point out was that officialdom in this case are trying to do the right thing by us 2-wheeled enthusiasts. The knockers on bike forums are largely knuckle-draggers who contribute nothing to any worthwhile initiative.

      Totally agree re the truck. He was doing his best to be courteous given that it is a long way down that hill. I wouldn't have gone in a car though in case there was a quick vehicle coming the other way. Looking at improving pull-over points on the Loop is part of the project.

      Delete
  4. Wow, a country that is actually trying to make roads safer for motorcycles, that is good to hear.

    It seem odd to me to add helipads beside the roads with the added cost. Whenever life flight is needed here they just block the roads and land right in the middle if there isn't anywhere else.

    Thanks for the write up Geoff.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Brandy,
      Yep, it's good news! They also drop choppers onto the road in NZ where appropriate. However, in the Coromandel area, police, fire and ambulance services are few and far between and traffic control could be an issue in some of the more remote locations - a chopper could arrive well before any proper ground control. Hence the helipads just off the road.

      Delete
    2. NZ and Aussie Roads Brandy are often far smaller in size than their American counterparts, meaning a chopper cannot land on the road because the road isn't big enough to take one so they build helipads to the side of the road in cetain spots so they can get in and out. We have a few here on some motorcycle roads, in particular the Old Pacific Hwy is an Motorcycle road in Sydney with Helipads which are used far too often I might add.

      Delete
  5. Hi Geoff
    What a great post and I'm glad that you could provide assistance to a governmetn department that is actually trying to help make road conditions better rather than just slap the speed limit down by 40kmh and then throw a huge amount of Highway patrol on it to make sure people are complying to the new lower limits, as thats exactly what happen here in Australia. Theres no trying to make the road better just Compliance control.
    I really hope you guys don't follow what we do here.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Hi Steve,
    If we're going to make real progress in bringing the road toll down, everyone has to be on board, not just the police or any other government agency. I'd like to think that as a biker, I've identified some improvement opportunities that non-riders would have missed. Ultimately, we all have to ride appropriately to the conditions and hopefully, raising riding standards will help to address that.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Good article and Blog Geoff, good to see Govt doing the right thing. Can only hope they apply the same logic to other black spots for bikers around NZ. I know a couple of NZTA guys who are bikers will be helping us behind the scenes so a big thank you to them from us peasants...LOL

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I think this is very much of a trial but there's a real enthusiasm for doing something positive rather than punitive. I wish them every success too! There's no magic bullet but the combination of a whole load of small gains by all stakeholders should see some significant improvements. Thanks for the comments!

      Delete
  8. Hi Geoff, good to see your write up. It appears that the authorities are genuinely prepared to spend money on an holistic solution? I agree that a lot of people don't take sufficient responsibility for their lack of riding skill but historically the authorities haven't shown much care. Could that all be about to change? I hope so and you sound very positive. I hope they take on board your undoubtedly valuable input to the problems and equally to the possible solutions. I know this is going to seem cynical and I hate to " look a gift horse in the mouth" but once the improvements have been implemented, will the speed cameras follow to pay for it?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Barry,
      It's certainly a refreshing initiative but nothing is guaranteed in this life other than death and taxes. If there's a good result, then it's likely to continue on a wider scale I'd imagine. The big question is how do we encourage riders to upskilled?

      Delete
  9. Hi Geoff - what a great initiative. It's certainly good to see and goes a bit of the way towards countering the negative view that (most?) people have of roading authorities. Having partaken of the Coro GP track myself on many an occasion, there certainly are a lot of areas that could be improved upon - espec. for the less confident/over confident rider and, as they have done over here on our local roads(shock horror)little things like trimming back vegetation and improving sight lines can make a big difference. It must feel good to be able to have an input - espec with your newer "IAM eye"

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Jon,
      Yep, good on the authorities and I hope it's a success and gets spread wider. It's great to be able to contribute and it's been hinted that I may be asked to present a paper on the process at an international roading conference in May. Thought all that sort of thing stopped when I retired!

      Delete
  10. Good write up - thanks Geoff - Jim F

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Jim - long time no see!

      Many thanks. Excellent people, practical solutions. Had a meeting with two of the people associated with the project on Saturday and look forward to the next steps!


      Cheers :-)

      Delete